A brief lesson in logic

These last 2 posts at iBlog for Cookies definitely deserve some cookies as a brief lesson in how to gather data and construct an argument. Just a guess, but I think he's had some experience critically evaluating journal articles.

Either way, I've got to agree with his points. There are valid criticisms of Lloyd Carr. But just digging up stats to try to prove your point isn't the best way of convincing the unconvinced.